Trying to Conceive? This Sperm Test Could Uncover a Hidden Fertility Factor
Even with a normal semen analysis, hidden genetic damage in sperm can drive recurrent pregnancy loss. Experts break down sperm DNA fragmentation, heat risks, and the critical 74-day “trimester zero” window.
-
Click here to listen to this article - Share via
A couple experiences a miscarriage, then another. The woman undergoes scans, bloodwork, and a series of specialist referrals. The man’s semen analysis comes back normal (decent count, good motility, typical shape), yet the losses continue without explanation.
Melissa Magsaysay sat down with a reproductive urologist and a fertility-focused entrepreneur on the most recent episode of the Live + Well podcast to unpack a number most couples never hear in a doctor’s office. 74.
RELATED: The Pregnancy Nutrition Advice You’re Probably Not Getting
That is roughly how many days it takes a man’s body to produce a new batch of sperm, a window some clinicians call trimester zero.
Struggling to conceive? Male fertility accounts for 50% of challenges. Watch to discover how to boost sperm health during Trimester Zero.
What Is Sperm DNA Fragmentation and Trimester Zero?
A standard semen analysis can check sperm from the outside. How many are there? How well do they move? What shape are they in?
“The framework is a semen analysis sort of helps us look at everything from the outside,” said James Weinberger, MD, a reproductive urologist and Director of Men’s Health and Fertility at Reproductive Partners Medical Group in Beverly Hills. “It doesn’t really let us look under the hood.”
RELATED: How Nicotinamide Riboside (NR) Is Linked to Increased NAD Levels and Healthy Aging
What is under the hood, in this case, is the genetic material packed inside the sperm head, which is what a DNA fragmentation index (DFI) test actually measures.
The male factor plays a role in roughly half of infertility cases, Weinberger says. Weinberger is one of a small number of urologists nationally trained in male infertility microsurgery, and his caseload reflects a pattern the research keeps circling back to.
A man can have a technically normal semen analysis and still carry sperm with damaged DNA. Elevated fragmentation correlates directly with lower rates of embryo progression and higher rates of miscarriage across natural conception, IUI, and IVF. “It really matters to the end points that are the most important,” Weinberger noted.
How Male Factor Infertility and Scrotal Heat Impact Miscarriage Risk
Studies show that male partners of women with recurrent pregnancy loss had significantly higher rates of sperm DNA fragmentation than fertile controls, and Weinberger sees that as well, pointing to varicoceles....enlarged veins in the scrotum that can raise local temperature and drive up oxidative stress, essentially free radicals overwhelming the sperm’s natural defenses.
“It really takes a physical exam, a history, a hormone check, and a semen analysis to get the full picture,” he explains, describing how his team decides whether a patient needs the more specialized test.
Weinberger pushed back on some of the folklore around male fertility, but confirmed one piece of it... regular hot tub use, at 100 to 104 degrees a few times a week, “can bring guys with normal sperm counts all the way to zero.” That one is real, he says.
RELATED: The One Biological Metric That Determines if You’re Actually Recovering (It’s Not Sleep)
Ronit Menashe, co-founder of the prenatal supplement company WeNatal, joined the conversation from a different angle. She shared that she experienced two miscarriages, and that her own research afterward led her to the same statistic as Weinberger. A meaningful share of pregnancy loss traces back to sperm quality.
“We put my husband on antioxidants shown to improve sperm quality,” Menashe said, describing the three months before she conceived her daughter at 42. She talked about men as underestimated players in the process.
A closer look at how Costco’s fertility program is reshaping cost, access, and what it takes to stay in fertility treatment.
When to Get a DFI Test for Male Fertility Health
For men who want a baseline without the specialized workup, standard at-home kits offer a reasonable starting point, though they do not capture DNA fragmentation specifically. A DFI test is typically reserved for couples with recurrent loss or failed IVF and IUI cycles, since it requires a more specialized lab process than a routine semen analysis.
RELATED: Social Media Algorithms Ban Menopause Ads While Welcoming Erectile Dysfunction
“A fragmentation test is guideline-recommended for patients who have recurrent miscarriage,” Weinberger said, “so the evidence there is really quite strong.”
Semen quality tracks with more than fertility, Weinberger added, calling it a kind of sixth vital sign, “the same way a semen analysis is a check engine light for a man’s health.”
Listen to the full conversation with Dr. James Weinberger and Ronit Menashe Spotify on Spotify or Apple Podcasts.
